Opinion details

GET/opinions/{id}/

One court opinion, with its text, by opinion ID (opinion IDs do not match cluster IDs).

Listed by OrthogonalPublished by CourtListenerPublisher docs
curl -X POST https://api.orthogonal.com/v1/run \
-H 'Authorization: Bearer orth_live_••••' \
-H 'Content-Type: application/json' \
-d '{
"api": "courtlistener",
"path": "",
"method": "GET"
}'
{
"success": true,
"data": {
"id": 9969234,
"html": "",
"sha1": "fba1b7a149b21c7378719ec3c8f81eb8f76638f9",
"type": "010combined",
"author": "[redacted]",
"cluster": "https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/clusters/9502621/",
"xml_scan": "",
"author_id": "[redacted]",
"joined_by": [],
"author_str": "[redacted]",
"cluster_id": 9502621,
"local_path": "pdf/2024/05/15/robinson_v._callais.pdf",
"page_count": 3,
"per_curiam": false,
"plain_text": " Cite as: 601 U. S. ____ (2024) 1\n\n JACKSON, J., dissenting\n\nSUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES\n _________________\n\n No. 23A994\n _________________\n\n\nPRESS ROBINSON, ET AL. v. PHILLIP CALLAIS, ET AL.\n ON APPLICATION FOR STAY\n _________________\n\n No. 23A1002\n _________________\n\n\n NANCY LANDRY, SECRETARY OF STATE OF\n LOUISIANA, ET AL. v. PHILLIP CALLAIS, ET AL.\n ON APPLICATION FOR STAY\n\n\n [May 15, 2024]\n\n The applications for stay presented to JUSTICE ALITO\nand by him referred to the Court are granted. See Purcell\nv. Gonzalez, 549 U. S. 1 (2006). The April 30, 2024 order of\nthe United States District Court for the Western District of\nLouisiana, case No. 3:24–cv–00122, is stayed pending the\ntimely docketing of the appeal in this Court. Should the\njurisdictional statement be timely filed, this order shall re-\nmain in effect pending this Court’s action on the appeal. If\nthe appeal is dismissed, or the judgment affirmed, this or-\nder shall terminate automatically. In the event jurisdiction\nis noted or postponed, this order will remain in effect pend-\ning the sending down of the judgment of this Court.\n JUSTICE SOTOMAYOR and JUSTICE KAGAN would deny the\napplications for stay.\n JUSTICE JACKSON, dissenting from grant of applications\nfor stay.\n These emergency applications arise from a complex series\nof cases about what district lines Louisiana voters should\nuse to select their Congressional Representatives. Over\n�2 ROBINSON v. CALLAIS\n\n JACKSON, J., dissenting\n\nmore than two years of litigation, separate groups of voters\nhave challenged Louisiana’s congressional maps, first for\nviolating §2 of the Voting Rights Act and now for violating\nthe Equal Protection Clause of the Constitution. The Loui-\nsiana Legislature, two Governors, civil rights organiza-\ntions, voters, and jurists at every level of our federal system\nhave weighed in on these challenges. That careful scrutiny\nis fitting: The question of how to elect representatives con-\nsistent with our shared commitment to racial equality is\namong the most consequential we face as a democracy.\n The question before us today, though, is far more quotid-\nian: When does Louisiana need a new map for the Novem-\nber 2024 election? Redistricting raises unique and unusual\ntimeliness concerns, with important deadlines weeks and\neven months before an election. The three-judge District\nCourt in this action, after holding a full merits trial and\nfinding the current map unconstitutional, scheduled the\nimposition of a remedial map for no later than June 4. In\ndoing so, it rejected the State’s argument that the real dead-\nline for settling on a map is May 15. The State now renews\nthose arguments before us, asserting that waiting any\nlonger will result in irreparable harm, namely, “election\nchaos.” Emergency Application in No. 23A1002, p. 19. The\nCourt appears to credit the State’s arguments, relying on\nthe so-called Purcell principle that courts making changes\nto election procedures close to an election must consider the\npossibility of “voter confusion.” Purcell v. Gonzalez, 549\nU. S. 1, 4–5 (2006) (per curiam).\n In my view, Purcell has no role to play here. There is\nlittle risk of voter confusion from a new map being imposed\nthis far out from the November election. In fact, we have\noften denied stays of redistricting orders issued as close or\ncloser to an election. See Merrill v. Milligan, 595 U. S. ___,\n___–___ (2022) (KAGAN, J., dissenting from grant of appli-\ncations for stays) (slip op., at 10–11) (collecting cases). Of\ncourse, administrative difficulties may occur if a new map\n� Cite as: 601 U. S. ____ (2024) 3\n\n JACKSON, J., dissenting\n\nis imposed late in an election cycle. But, as the Fifth Circuit\nnoted in rejecting similar Purcell arguments by the State in\nadvance of the 2022 election, “ ‘[ i]f time presses too seri-\nously, the District Court has the power appropriately to ex-\ntend’ . . . deadline[s] and other ‘time limitations imposed by\nstate law.’ ” Robinson v. Ardoin, 37 F. 4th 208, 230 (2022)\n(per curiam) (quoting Sixty-seventh Minnesota State Senate\nv. Beens, 406 U. S. 187, 201, n. 11 (1972) (per curiam)).\n Rather than wading in now, I would have let the District\nCourt’s remedial process run its course before considering\nwhether our emergency intervention was warranted.*\nTherefore, I respectfully dissent.\n\n\n\n\n——————\n *In a separate application, intervenors from the earlier Voting Rights\nAct litigation allege that they will face irreparable harm if subjected to\nanother election under a map that likely violates §2. See Emergency\nApplication in No. 23A994, p. 40. That harm is serious, but it was, at the\ntime of these emergency filings, highly contingent. The District Court\nhas not yet selected a remedial map, and, were it not for this Court’s\nintervention, it may have selected a map that complies with both §2 and\nthe Equal Protection Clause. I would have waited until after the reme-\ndial process concluded (when it would have been clearer if the interve-\nnors’ faced irreparable harm) to consider their arguments.\n�",
"html_lawbox": "",
"xml_harvard": "",
"absolute_url": "/opinion/9502621/robinson-v-callais/",
"date_created": "2024-05-15T15:01:06.336515-07:00",
"download_url": "https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/23pdf/23a994_7mip.pdf",
"main_version": null,
"ordering_key": null,
"resource_uri": "https://www.courtlistener.com/api/rest/v4/opinions/9969234/",
"date_modified": "2025-12-04T19:42:13.814185-08:00",
"html_columbia": "",
"joined_by_str": "",
"html_anon_2020": "",
"opinions_cited": [ 3 items ],
"extracted_by_ocr": false,
"html_with_citations": "<pre class=\"inline\"> Cite as: </pre><span class=\"citation no-link\">601 U. S. ____</span><pre class=\"inline\"> (2024) 1\n\n JACKSON, J., dissenting\n\nSUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES\n _________________\n\n No. 23A994\n _________________\n\n\nPRESS ROBINSON, ET AL. v. PHILLIP CALLAIS, ET AL.\n ON APPLICATION FOR STAY\n _________________\n\n No. 23A1002\n _________________\n\n\n NANCY LANDRY, SECRETARY OF STATE OF\n LOUISIANA, ET AL. v. PHILLIP CALLAIS, ET AL.\n ON APPLICATION FOR STAY\n\n\n [May 15, 2024]\n\n The applications for stay presented to JUSTICE ALITO\nand by him referred to the Court are granted. See Purcell\nv. Gonzalez, </pre><span class=\"citation\" data-id=\"9435151\"><a href=\"/opinion/145774/purcell-v-gonzalez/\" aria-description=\"Citation for case: Purcell v. Gonzalez\">549 U. S. 1</a></span><pre class=\"inline\"> (2006). The April 30, 2024 order of\nthe United States District Court for the Western District of\nLouisiana, case No. 3:24–cv–00122, is stayed pending the\ntimely docketing of the appeal in this Court. Should the\njurisdictional statement be timely filed, this order shall re-\nmain in effect pending this Court’s action on the appeal. If\nthe appeal is dismissed, or the judgment affirmed, this or-\nder shall terminate automatically. In the event jurisdiction\nis noted or postponed, this order will remain in effect pend-\ning the sending down of the judgment of this Court.\n JUSTICE SOTOMAYOR and JUSTICE KAGAN would deny the\napplications for stay.\n JUSTICE JACKSON, dissenting from grant of applications\nfor stay.\n These emergency applications arise from a complex series\nof cases about what district lines Louisiana voters should\nuse to select their Congressional Representatives. Over\n�2 ROBINSON v. CALLAIS\n\n JACKSON, J., dissenting\n\nmore than two years of litigation, separate groups of voters\nhave challenged Louisiana’s congressional maps, first for\nviolating §2 of the Voting Rights Act and now for violating\nthe Equal Protection Clause of the Constitution. The Loui-\nsiana Legislature, two Governors, civil rights organiza-\ntions, voters, and jurists at every level of our federal system\nhave weighed in on these challenges. That careful scrutiny\nis fitting: The question of how to elect representatives con-\nsistent with our shared commitment to racial equality is\namong the most consequential we face as a democracy.\n The question before us today, though, is far more quotid-\nian: When does Louisiana need a new map for the Novem-\nber 2024 election? Redistricting raises unique and unusual\ntimeliness concerns, with important deadlines weeks and\neven months before an election. The three-judge District\nCourt in this action, after holding a full merits trial and\nfinding the current map unconstitutional, scheduled the\nimposition of a remedial map for no later than June 4. In\ndoing so, it rejected the State’s argument that the real dead-\nline for settling on a map is May 15. The State now renews\nthose arguments before us, asserting that waiting any\nlonger will result in irreparable harm, namely, “election\nchaos.” Emergency Application in No. 23A1002, p. 19. The\nCourt appears to credit the State’s arguments, relying on\nthe so-called Purcell principle that courts making changes\nto election procedures close to an election must consider the\npossibility of “voter confusion.” Purcell v. Gonzalez, </pre><span class=\"citation\" data-id=\"9435151\"><a href=\"/opinion/145774/purcell-v-gonzalez/\" aria-description=\"Citation for case: Purcell v. Gonzalez\">549\nU. S. 1</a></span><pre class=\"inline\">, 4–5 (2006) (per curiam).\n In my view, Purcell has no role to play here. There is\nlittle risk of voter confusion from a new map being imposed\nthis far out from the November election. In fact, we have\noften denied stays of redistricting orders issued as close or\ncloser to an election. See Merrill v. Milligan, </pre><span class=\"citation no-link\">595 U. S. ___</span><pre class=\"inline\">,\n___–___ (2022) (KAGAN, J., dissenting from grant of appli-\ncations for stays) (slip op., at 10–11) (collecting cases). Of\ncourse, administrative difficulties may occur if a new map\n� Cite as: </pre><span class=\"citation no-link\">601 U. S. ____</span><pre class=\"inline\"> (2024) 3\n\n JACKSON, J., dissenting\n\nis imposed late in an election cycle. But, as the Fifth Circuit\nnoted in rejecting similar Purcell arguments by the State in\nadvance of the 2022 election, “ ‘[ i]f time presses too seri-\nously, the District Court has the power appropriately to ex-\ntend’ . . . deadline[s] and other ‘time limitations imposed by\nstate law.’ ” Robinson v. Ardoin, </pre><span class=\"citation\" data-id=\"6348952\"><a href=\"/opinion/6476841/robinson-v-ardoin/#230\" aria-description=\"Citation for case: Robinson v. Ardoin\">37 F. 4th 208, 230</a></span><pre class=\"inline\"> (2022)\n(per curiam) (quoting Sixty-seventh Minnesota State Senate\nv. Beens, </pre><span class=\"citation\" data-id=\"9424859\"><a href=\"/opinion/108529/sixty-seventh-minnesota-state-senate-v-beens/#201\" aria-description=\"Citation for case: Sixty-Seventh Minnesota State Senate v. Beens\">406 U. S. 187, 201, n. 11</a></span><pre class=\"inline\"> (1972) (per curiam)).\n Rather than wading in now, I would have let the District\nCourt’s remedial process run its course before considering\nwhether our emergency intervention was warranted.*\nTherefore, I respectfully dissent.\n\n\n\n\n——————\n *In a separate application, intervenors from the earlier Voting Rights\nAct litigation allege that they will face irreparable harm if subjected to\nanother election under a map that likely violates §2. See Emergency\nApplication in No. 23A994, p. 40. That harm is serious, but it was, at the\ntime of these emergency filings, highly contingent. The District Court\nhas not yet selected a remedial map, and, were it not for this Court’s\nintervention, it may have selected a map that complies with both §2 and\nthe Equal Protection Clause. I would have waited until after the reme-\ndial process concluded (when it would have been clearer if the interve-\nnors’ faced irreparable harm) to consider their arguments.\n�</pre>"
}
}
A real response, recorded when Orthogonal checked this endpoint.

$0.00218per call

Path parameters

Query parameters

More from CourtListener

  1. Judge listGET/people/$0.00218 per call
  2. Judge reimbursementsGET/reimbursements/$0.00218 per call
  3. Oral argument listGET/audio/$0.00218 per call
  4. Citation graphGET/opinions-cited/$0.00218 per call
  5. Judicial positionsGET/positions/$0.00218 per call
  6. Judge investmentsGET/investments/$0.00218 per call
  7. Docket detailsGET/dockets/{id}/$0.00218 per call
  8. Judge outside positionsGET/disclosure-positions/$0.00218 per call
  9. Judge giftsGET/gifts/$0.00218 per call
  10. Judge data sourcesGET/sources/$0.00218 per call
  11. Judge agreementsGET/agreements/$0.00218 per call
  12. Citation lookupPOST/citation-lookup/$0.00545 per call
All 39 CourtListener endpoints